Mastering Pinterest: The Importance of Pinner Quality in the Algorithm

When it comes to building a successful Pinterest strategy, we often focus on optimizing our Pins and perfecting our website. But today, let’s talk about something more personal — you. The way you, as a user, interact with Pinterest plays a crucial role in how the platform views your account. This is called Pinner Quality, and it’s an essential factor in the Pinterest algorithm.

What is Pinner Quality?

Pinner Quality refers to how Pinterest evaluates your overall activity and engagement on the platform. It’s a measure of how often you’re pinning, interacting with other users, and contributing to the Pinterest community. Are you pinning consistently? Are you engaging with other people’s Pins by repinning, liking, or commenting? These activities signal to the algorithm that you are an active and valuable user, which can boost the visibility of your content.


Think of Pinterest as an algorithmic garden — the more you nurture it through regular, meaningful interactions, the better your content will perform. Consistency is key. If you pin your content regularly, engage with others by repinning high-quality Pins, and follow relevant accounts, you are essentially “watering” your Pinterest garden.

The Power of Consistent Engagement

One of the most effective ways to improve your Pinner Quality is by staying active. When you consistently pin fresh content, it shows Pinterest that your account is worth promoting. Pinterest loves active users, and the algorithm rewards accounts that stay engaged over time. This means creating new Pins, engaging with other Pinners’ content, and diversifying your activity.
Building a strong Pinterest Business account can feel overwhelming at first, but the key is to make Pinterest a part of your routine. In my quick, actionable guide, How to Stay Consistent, DailyI share actionable ways to incorporate Pinterest into your daily workflow, ensuring that you’re regularly engaging with the platform in a sustainable way.

Understanding Engagement Rates

Pinner Quality isn’t just about how often you pin—it’s also about how well your Pins perform. Pinterest tracks how other users interact with your content through metrics like repins, clicks, and saves. If your Pins consistently receive high engagement, this signals to Pinterest that your content is valuable. The algorithm will, in turn, promote your Pins to a larger audience.


Reviewing your analytics can help you understand which of your Pins are performing well. Use these insights to create more content that resonates with your audience. Experiment with different Pin designs, titles, and keywords to boost your engagement rates.

Save for Later ⤵️

Follow Pinterest’s Community Guidelines

Lastly, adhering to Pinterest’s community guidelines is crucial for maintaining high Pinner Quality. Violating guidelines can harm your account’s credibility and even result in penalties. Make sure you’re familiar with these guidelines, which are outlined in Pinterest’s Community Guidelines.
By following the rules, engaging actively, and producing quality content, you can enhance your account’s standing and enjoy long-term success on the platform.

Sign up for my monthly newsletter for bite-sized nuggets on how to make Pinterest work for you. Frieda Creates For You is your one-stop spot for artists wanting to learn Pinterest.

Let’s Stay In Touch


Sign up for my monthly newsletter for news and know-how. Plus, you’ll receive helpful guides to support your Pinterest journey…especially attuned for artists and creative folks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

more blog posts

Hi, I'm Frieda

I coach artists on how to use Pinterest to market their work. Want someone else to do it? My management services have got you covered. 

Just want to dip in your big toe?

My monthly newsletter is a great place to start.